Nut Tree Capital Management and Caspian Capital File Definitive Proxy Materials Opposing Merger Between Martin Midstream Partners and Martin Resource Management Corporation
Nut Tree Capital Management and Caspian Capital, holding approximately 13.6% of Martin Midstream Partners (MMLP) common units, have filed definitive proxy materials opposing the proposed merger with Martin Midstream Resource at $4.02 per unit. The investors urge unitholders to vote against the merger at the December 30, 2024 Special Meeting, arguing that MMLP's value significantly exceeds the offered price. They criticize the merger's financial analysis as deeply flawed and highlight concerns about conflicts of interest in the negotiation process, particularly involving MRMC's control person, Ruben Martin, III.
Nut Tree Capital Management e Caspian Capital, che detengono circa il 13,6% delle unità ordinarie di Martin Midstream Partners (MMLP), hanno presentato documenti di delega definitivi contrari alla proposta di fusione con Martin Midstream Resource a 4,02 $ per unità. Gli investitori esortano gli azionisti a votare contro la fusione durante la Riunione Straordinaria del 30 dicembre 2024, sostenendo che il valore di MMLP supera di gran lunga il prezzo offerto. Criticano l'analisi finanziaria della fusione come profondamente difettosa e mettono in evidenza preoccupazioni riguardo ai conflitti di interesse nel processo di negoziazione, in particolare riguardo alla persona di controllo di MRMC, Ruben Martin, III.
Nut Tree Capital Management y Caspian Capital, que poseen aproximadamente el 13,6% de las unidades comunes de Martin Midstream Partners (MMLP), han presentado materiales de poder definitivos en oposición a la propuesta de fusión con Martin Midstream Resource a 4,02 $ por unidad. Los inversores instan a los accionistas a votar en contra de la fusión en la Reunión Especial del 30 de diciembre de 2024, argumentando que el valor de MMLP excede significativamente el precio ofrecido. Critican el análisis financiero de la fusión como gravemente defectuoso y destacan preocupaciones sobre los conflictos de interés en el proceso de negociación, especialmente en lo que respecta a la persona de control de MRMC, Ruben Martin, III.
Nut Tree Capital Management와 Caspian Capital는 약 Martin Midstream Partners (MMLP)의 일반 주식의 13.6%를 보유하고 있으며, 주당 4.02달러에 Martin Midstream Resource와의 제안된 합병에 반대하는 공식 위임장을 제출했습니다. 투자자들은 2024년 12월 30일 특별 회의에서 합병 반대 투표를 촉구하며 MMLP의 가치가 제안된 가격을 크게 초과한다고 주장하고 있습니다. 그들은 재정 분석이 심각하게 결함이 있다고 비판하며, 협상 과정에서 MRMC의 통제자 루벤 마르틴 III와 관련된 이해 상충에 대한 우려를 강조합니다.
Nut Tree Capital Management et Caspian Capital, détenant environ 13,6 % des unités ordinaires de Martin Midstream Partners (MMLP), ont déposé des documents de procuration définitifs s'opposant à la fusion proposée avec Martin Midstream Resource au prix de 4,02 $ par unité. Les investisseurs incitent les détenteurs d'unités à voter contre la fusion lors de la réunion extraordinaire du 30 décembre 2024, soutenant que la valeur de MMLP dépasse largement le prix proposé. Ils critiquent l'analyse financière de la fusion comme étant profondément défaillante et soulignent des préoccupations concernant les conflits d'intérêts dans le processus de négociation, en particulier en ce qui concerne la personne de contrôle de MRMC, Ruben Martin, III.
Nut Tree Capital Management und Caspian Capital, die etwa 13,6% der Stammaktien von Martin Midstream Partners (MMLP) halten, haben definitive Vollmachtsunterlagen eingereicht, die sich gegen die vorgeschlagene Fusion mit Martin Midstream Resource zu einem Preis von 4,02 $ pro Einheit wenden. Die Investoren fordern die Unithalter auf, bei der außerordentlichen Hauptversammlung am 30. Dezember 2024 gegen die Fusion zu stimmen und argumentieren, dass der Wert von MMLP den angebotenen Preis erheblich übersteigt. Sie kritisieren die finanzielle Analyse der Fusion als tiefgreifend fehlerhaft und heben Bedenken hinsichtlich von Interessenkonflikten im Verhandlungsprozess hervor, insbesondere in Bezug auf die Kontrollperson von MRMC, Ruben Martin, III.
- None.
- Potential undervaluation in merger price of $4.02 per unit according to major shareholders
- Alleged conflicts of interest in merger negotiation process
- Criticized financial analysis used to justify the merger
- Opposition from significant shareholders holding 13.6% of common units
Insights
This proxy battle over MMLP's proposed merger presents a significant opportunity for value investors. Two major shareholders controlling
The opposition by Nut Tree and Caspian Capital, both sophisticated institutional investors, suggests potential for price appreciation through either a higher bid or standalone value creation. Their argument centers on flawed valuation methodology and insider conflicts, particularly regarding MRMC's control person Ruben Martin III.
The tight timeline with a December 30 special meeting creates urgency and could lead to increased market activity. For existing unitholders, this presents a critical decision point between accepting immediate liquidity or potentially realizing higher value through continued independence.
The merger opposition highlights serious corporate governance concerns that warrant investor attention. The conflict of interest stemming from insider control raises red flags about the fairness of the transaction process. The criticisms of the financial analysis used to justify the deal price suggest potential procedural deficiencies in the board's decision-making process.
The involvement of two significant institutional investors with substantial holdings adds credibility to these governance concerns. Their decision to launch a formal proxy fight, backed by prominent law firms Olshan Frome Wolosky and Latham & Watkins, indicates strong conviction in their position and could influence other unitholders' votes.
Nut Tree and Caspian File Definitive Proxy Statement and Send Letter to Unitholders Urging them to Vote "AGAINST" the Merger at MMLP's Special Meeting to be Held on December 30, 2024
Nut Tree and Caspian Believe MMLP is Worth Far More than the Per Unit Price in the Merger
Merger is Insider Led Deal Presenting Massive Conflicts of Interest and MMLP Approval Was Based on Flawed and Biased Financial Analysis in Nut Tree and
Nut Tree and Caspian Highlight MMLP's Bright Future Prospects as a Publicly Traded Company, and Path to Superior Value Creation for Unitholders
In connection with the filing of the definitive proxy materials, Nut Tree and
- MMLP's common units are worth far more than the
$4.02 - The Company relied on a deeply flawed financial analysis used to justify the Merger that ignored the future prospects for MMLP, which stand to create additional value for unitholders; and
- The massive conflicts of interest in the Merger and its negotiation process demand the highest degree of scrutiny and skepticism from MMLP unitholders.
Nut Tree and
The full text of the letter can be viewed here and is also available at www.ProtectMMLPValue.com.
Advisors
Olshan Frome Wolosky LLP and Latham & Watkins LLP are serving as legal counsel to Nut Tree and
About Caspian Capital LP
Caspian Capital LP's absolute return strategy was founded in 1997 and is focused on performing, stressed, distressed corporate credit, and value equities.
About Nut Tree Capital Management LP
Nut Tree Capital, founded in 2015, implements a fundamentals-based strategy focused on distressed credit, stressed/event-driven credit and value equities. Nut Tree currently oversees
Contacts
For Investors:
John Ferguson/Joe Mills
Saratoga Proxy Consulting LLC
(212) 257-1311
info@saratogaproxy.com
For Media:
Jonathan Gasthalter/Nathaniel Garnick
Gasthalter & Co.
(212) 257-4170
View original content:SOURCE Nut Tree Capital Management and Caspian Capital
FAQ
What is the proposed merger price for MMLP units in December 2024?
When is MMLP's Special Meeting scheduled for the merger vote?
What percentage of MMLP units do Nut Tree and Caspian collectively own?
Why are Nut Tree and Caspian opposing MMLP's merger?
