STOCK TITAN

Air Products Files Investor Presentation Highlighting Successful Two-Pillar Strategy to Deliver Superior Shareholder Value

Rhea-AI Impact
(Low)
Rhea-AI Sentiment
(Neutral)
Tags

Air Products (NYSE: APD) has filed an investor presentation highlighting its successful two-pillar growth strategy and achievements under CEO Seifi Ghasemi's leadership. The company has delivered over $44 billion in shareholder value since 2014, with significant financial improvements including a 1,400bps expansion in adjusted EBITDA margin and ~11% adjusted EPS CAGR.

The company's strategy focuses on growing its core industrial gas business while developing its position in the clean hydrogen market. Air Products has allocated over 50% of total capital expenditures for FY 2023-2025 to its core business and secured several major clean hydrogen agreements, including a 15-year supply deal with TotalEnergies.

The presentation addresses Mantle Ridge's board nominations, defending the current board's expertise and raising concerns about Mantle Ridge's proposed executive chairman candidate.

Air Products (NYSE: APD) ha presentato una presentazione agli investitori evidenziando la sua riuscita strategia di crescita a due pilastri e i risultati conseguiti sotto la guida del CEO Seifi Ghasemi. L'azienda ha generato oltre 44 miliardi di dollari di valore per gli azionisti dal 2014, con significativi miglioramenti finanziari tra cui un'espansione di 1.400 punti base del margine EBITDA rettificato e un CAGR del ~11% dell'EPS rettificato.

La strategia dell'azienda si concentra sulla crescita del suo business di gas industriali core mentre sviluppa la sua posizione nel mercato dell'idrogeno pulito. Air Products ha destinato oltre il 50% delle spese in conto capitale totali per l'anno fiscale 2023-2025 al suo business core e ha firmato diversi importanti accordi sull'idrogeno pulito, incluso un contratto di fornitura di 15 anni con TotalEnergies.

La presentazione affronta le nomine del consiglio di Mantle Ridge, difendendo l'esperienza dell'attuale consiglio e sollevando preoccupazioni riguardo al candidato proposto per la carica di presidente esecutivo da parte di Mantle Ridge.

Air Products (NYSE: APD) ha presentado una presentación a inversores destacando su exitosa estrategia de crecimiento en dos pilares y los logros bajo el liderazgo del CEO Seifi Ghasemi. La compañía ha entregado más de 44 mil millones de dólares en valor para los accionistas desde 2014, con mejoras financieras significativas que incluyen una expansión de 1,400 puntos básicos en el margen EBITDA ajustado y un CAGR del ~11% en el EPS ajustado.

La estrategia de la compañía se centra en el crecimiento de su negocio principal de gases industriales mientras desarrolla su posición en el mercado del hidrógeno limpio. Air Products ha asignado más del 50% del total de gastos de capital para el año fiscal 2023-2025 a su negocio principal y ha asegurado varios acuerdos importantes de hidrógeno limpio, incluido un contrato de suministro de 15 años con TotalEnergies.

La presentación aborda las nominaciones al consejo de Mantle Ridge, defendiendo la experiencia del consejo actual y planteando preocupaciones sobre el candidato propuesto por Mantle Ridge para presidente ejecutivo.

에어 프로덕츠 (NYSE: APD)는 CEO 세이피 가세미의 리더십 하에 성공적인 두 축 성장 전략과 성과를 강조하는 투자자 발표를 제출했습니다. 회사는 2014년 이후로 4,400억 달러 이상의 주주 가치를 창출했으며, 조정된 EBITDA 마진이 1,400bps 확대되고 조정된 EPS CAGR이 약 11%로 상당한 재무 개선을 이루었습니다.

회사의 전략은 산업 가스 핵심 사업의 성장을 지속하는 동시에 청정 수소 시장에서의 위치를 개발하는 데 중점을 두고 있습니다. 에어 프로덕츠는 2023-2025 회계연도 동안 총 자본 지출의 50% 이상을 핵심 사업에 할당하고, 토탈에너지와의 15년 공급 계약을 포함한 여러 주요 청정 수소 계약을 체결했습니다.

발표에서는 맨틀 리지의 이사회 후보 지명을 다루며, 현재 이사회의 전문성을 방어하고 맨틀 리지에서 제안한 집행 회장 후보에 대한 우려를 제기하고 있습니다.

Air Products (NYSE: APD) a soumis une présentation aux investisseurs mettant en évidence sa stratégie de croissance à deux volets et ses réalisations sous la direction du PDG Seifi Ghasemi. L'entreprise a généré plus de 44 milliards de dollars de valeur pour les actionnaires depuis 2014, avec des améliorations financières significatives, notamment une expansion de 1 400 points de base de la marge EBITDA ajustée et un taux de croissance annuel composé (CAGR) de ~11% de l'EPS ajusté.

La stratégie de l'entreprise se concentre sur la croissance de son activité principale de gaz industriels tout en développant sa position sur le marché de l'hydrogène propre. Air Products a alloué plus de 50 % de ses dépenses en capital totales pour l'exercice 2023-2025 à son activité principale et a sécurisé plusieurs accords majeurs sur l'hydrogène propre, y compris un contrat de fourniture de 15 ans avec TotalEnergies.

La présentation aborde les nominations au conseil d'administration de Mantle Ridge, défendant l'expertise du conseil actuel et exprimant des préoccupations concernant le candidat proposé par Mantle Ridge pour le poste de président exécutif.

Air Products (NYSE: APD) hat eine Präsentation für Investoren eingereicht, in der die erfolgreiche Wachstumsstrategie mit zwei Säulen und die Ergebnisse unter der Leitung von CEO Seifi Ghasemi hervorgehoben werden. Das Unternehmen hat seit 2014 über 44 Milliarden Dollar an Aktionärswerten geliefert, mit erheblichen finanziellen Verbesserungen, darunter eine Expansion des angepassten EBITDA-Margins um 1.400 Basispunkte und ein CAGR von etwa 11% beim angepassten EPS.

Die Strategie des Unternehmens konzentriert sich darauf, sein Kerngeschäft mit Industriegasen auszubauen und gleichzeitig seine Position im Markt für sauberen Wasserstoff zu stärken. Air Products hat über 50% der gesamten Investitionsausgaben für die Geschäftsjahre 2023-2025 seinem Kerngeschäft zugewiesen und mehrere bedeutende Vereinbarungen für sauberen Wasserstoff gesichert, darunter einen 15-Jahres-Liefervertrag mit TotalEnergies.

Die Präsentation behandelt die Board-Nominierungen von Mantle Ridge, verteidigt die Expertise des aktuellen Boards und äußert Bedenken hinsichtlich des von Mantle Ridge vorgeschlagenen Kandidaten für den Posten des Executive Chairman.

Positive
  • Delivered $44 billion in shareholder value creation since 2014
  • Achieved 1,400bps expansion in adjusted EBITDA margin
  • Maintained ~11% adjusted EPS CAGR
  • Secured 15-year take-or-pay agreement with TotalEnergies for green hydrogen supply
  • 60% of capacity already committed for Canada Net-Zero Hydrogen Energy Project
  • 42 consecutive years of dividend increases with ~9% CAGR over past 10 years
Negative
  • Clean hydrogen investments not expected to generate positive net cash until FY2027

Insights

This investor presentation and proxy battle defense represents a critical moment for Air Products. The company's defense against Mantle Ridge's activist campaign centers on two key elements: $44 billion in shareholder value creation under current CEO Seifi Ghasemi and the company's strategic positioning in the emerging clean hydrogen market.

The financials are compelling - 11% adjusted EPS CAGR, 1,400 bps EBITDA margin expansion and 4% sales CAGR outpacing peers. The company's focus on pricing power and stable on-site revenues has created a resilient business model. The 42 consecutive years of dividend increases demonstrate strong cash generation capabilities.

However, the proxy battle raises serious governance concerns. The allegations about board nominee Dennis Reilley's potential involvement in insider trading while serving as a director at other companies is particularly troubling from a governance perspective. The market typically reacts negatively to such leadership uncertainty.

Air Products' strategic positioning in clean hydrogen represents a massive market opportunity with the sector projected to reach $600 billion by 2030. The company's first-mover advantage is critical, having already secured significant contracts like the 70,000-ton annual supply agreement with TotalEnergies and the NEOM Green Hydrogen Complex project.

The four key competitive advantages - land scarcity, supply chain partners, customer agreements and financing partnerships - create substantial barriers to entry. With 65 years of hydrogen experience, Air Products has the technical expertise to capitalize on the transition from fossil fuels, which currently represent 80% of global energy consumption.

The projected positive cash flow by FY2027 suggests a well-planned expansion strategy into clean hydrogen while maintaining core business growth.

The proxy battle presents significant governance risks. The proposed removal of four key directors would eliminate important expertise in operations, legal affairs and energy projects. Particularly concerning is Mantle Ridge's track record - their previous campaigns at Aramark, CSX and Dollar Tree have underperformed the S&P 500.

The allegations surrounding Dennis Reilley's past board service and the related FBI investigation raise serious red flags. His resignation from three boards shortly before these issues became public and subsequent absence from public company boards for six years warrant careful scrutiny.

The current board's composition, with six out of nine directors appointed in the last five years, demonstrates commitment to regular refreshment while maintaining stability and expertise.

The Company's Board and Management, Under Chairman and CEO Seifi Ghasemi's Leadership, Have Delivered Over $44 Billion in Shareholder Value Creation1

Continues to Successfully Execute Two-Pillar Growth Strategy to Grow Core Industrial Gas Business While Capitalizing on First-Mover Advantage in Clean Hydrogen Market

Air Products' Board is Refreshed, Independent and Fit-For-Purpose –
Mantle Ridge's Proposed Nominees Would Remove Significant and Relevant Experience and Expertise

Mantle Ridge's Proposed Executive Chairman Candidate Appears Alarmingly Unfit to Lead Air Products or any Public Company; Preferred CEO Candidate is Insufficiently Qualified

Board Mails Letter Urging Shareholders to Vote "FOR" ONLY Air Products' Nominees on the WHITE Proxy Card

LEHIGH VALLEY, Pa., Dec. 18, 2024 /PRNewswire/ -- Air Products (NYSE: APD) Board of Directors today announced that it has posted an investor presentation and mailed a letter to shareholders in connection with its upcoming 2025 Annual Meeting of Shareholders (the "Annual Meeting"), which will be held at 8:30 a.m. U.S. Eastern Time on January 23, 2025. All Air Products shareholders of record as of the close of business on November 27, 2024 will be entitled to vote at the Annual Meeting. The presentation and letter are both available at voteairproducts.com.

The full text of the letter summarizing the presentation follows:

Dear Fellow Shareholder,

The Air Products Annual Meeting is fast approaching, and you have an important opportunity to protect the value of your investment and the meaningful results the Company has delivered and anticipates continuing to deliver – as we have for the past 10 years. Under the supervision of our Board, management is executing a long-term strategy to grow our core industrial gas business, while leveraging decades of relevant expertise to capitalize on our important first-mover position in the clean hydrogen market to deliver maximized value for our shareholders.

We ask that you please visit our Annual Meeting website at voteairproducts.com or the Company Investor Relations page to find a new investor presentation that we filed today, entitled "Creating Superior Shareholder Value Through Disciplined Investment in Clean Hydrogen," where we go through, in greater detail, why our long-term growth strategy is the right one, why Air Products' Nominees are the necessary leaders to move Air Products forward, and why shareholders should not support Mantle Ridge's nominees.

We recommend you vote your shares "FOR" ONLY Air Products' Nominees – Tonit M. Calaway, Charles Cogut, Lisa A. Davis, Seifollah Ghasemi, Jessica Trocchi Graziano, Edward L. Monser, Bhavesh V. ("Bob") Patel, Wayne T. Smith and Alfred Stern – on the Company's WHITE proxy card.

OVER THE PAST DECADE UNDER THE LEADERSHIP OF OUR CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER, SEIFI GHASEMI, AIR PRODUCTS HAS CREATED OVER $44 BILLION IN SHAREHOLDER VALUE2

Since Mr. Ghasemi became CEO in 2014, he has spearheaded the transformation of Air Products into the most profitable industrial gas business in the world based on adjusted EBITDA margin, growing the business at GDP-plus rates. This strong cash generation has allowed Air Products to invest in our core industrial gas business, while expanding into clean hydrogen – a tremendous growth opportunity now and well into the future.

Our strong performance has directly benefitted shareholders through $11.5 billion in cash returned since 2014. In addition, our dividend per share has increased for 42 consecutive years and grown at a ~9% CAGR for the past 10 years, demonstrating our commitment to sharing with our investors the value we create. Including dividends, Air Products has delivered over $44 billion in total shareholder value3 over the last decade under Mr. Ghasemi's leadership.  

During Mr. Ghasemi's tenure, the Company has delivered the following key financial outcomes:

  • Expanded adjusted EBITDA margin4 by +1,400 bps
  • Achieved ~11% adjusted EPS CAGR5
  • Significant pricing and volume gains
  • Sales have grown at a ~4% CAGR – higher than each public peer6

Under Mr. Ghasemi's direction, the Company has continuously pushed for profitability improvements and has been increasing its price-cost spread. This has been accomplished through favorable contract modifications over time, resulting in an increased contribution of stable on-site revenues. Further improvement and growth of the core industrial gas business are ongoing, and the Board and management team remain focused on maximizing value over the long-term.  

AIR PRODUCTS IS SUCCESSFULLY EXECUTING A TWO-PILLAR GROWTH STRATEGY TO CONTINUE DRIVING VALUE CREATION INTO THE FUTURE

We remain focused on investing in, and growing, our core industrial gas business, which delivers industry-leading profitability based on adjusted EBITDA margin,7 while advancing our first-mover advantage in the clean hydrogen market. We have allocated more than 50% of our total capital expenditures for FY 2023-2025 to our core business, underscoring our commitment to its continued growth. We have already launched multiple projects in recent years aimed at improving capacity, increasing efficiencies and reaching new industrial gas markets.

In tandem with these investments, Air Products is positioning the core business to capture opportunities for growth in expanding market segments. For instance, we have accumulated a critical mass of infrastructure strategically placed next to global electronics providers' fabrication facilities, orienting our core industrial gas business to benefit from data center, AI and CHIPS Act tailwinds.

As a result of this approach, we have achieved significant tangible benefits to the business. Our on-site core capabilities model is driving resilience through a balanced mix of on-site and merchant sales. We are more heavily weighted toward the stable, infrastructure-like on-site business model than our peers, strengthening the durability of our business.

At the same time, we are expanding into clean hydrogen, a market with immense long-term potential:

  • Today, 80% of the global energy market is fossil fuel-based,8 with clean hydrogen poised to play a major role in diversifying the mix of energy sources.
  • Clean hydrogen can be a source of energy like oil or gas but releases no climate-warming carbon dioxide, making it an ideal fuel for the future amid a global push to decarbonize emissions.
  • To grow long-term volumes, satisfy global decarbonization regulation, effectively serve evolving customer needs, and remain competitive, the industrial gases sector must invest in clean hydrogen capabilities.

According to independent experts, the clean hydrogen market is expected to be worth more than $600 billion by 2030 and exceed $1 trillion by 2050.9 Clean hydrogen may contribute up to 20% of total global abatement needed by 2050.10 Clean hydrogen is anticipated to have applications across a diverse array of end markets including road transport, shipping, iron, aluminum and steel, chemicals and petrochemicals, and power generation.

No company is better positioned than Air Products – with more than 65 years of hydrogen experience – to meet the growing demand in this space, by serving global customers across industries working to improve efficiency and reliability while reducing emissions. Initially capturing even a small portion of the clean hydrogen market would provide incredible value for shareholders.

FIRST-MOVER ADVANTAGE IS ABSOLUTELY CRITICAL TO SUCCESS IN THE CLEAN HYDROGEN MARKET – AND WE ARE SEEING EARLY RESULTS

There are four key elements that make being the first mover in clean hydrogen incredibly crucial, and where Air Products has an edge:

  • Land scarcity: Access to ample resources such as sun and wind are critical to produce green hydrogen; and the right geology, large land plots, low-cost natural gas for carbon sequestration, and skilled labor are essential for blue hydrogen production.
  • Limited supply chain partners: Supply chain logistics are complex, and the necessary intellectual property and partners are limited.
  • Securing best-in-class customer agreements: We have the best seat at the table to negotiate offtake agreements with customers.
  • Obtaining highest-quality financing partners: Meaningful capital investment is needed to secure the backing of financing partners with the proper scale and industry expertise.

Underpinning our advantage in these four important areas are the critical developments of proprietary knowledge and intellectual property, which enable a first-mover advantage to transition into a world-leading position.

Capturing a small portion of market share now will compound as the market continues to expand.

Because of our foresight and strategic investment, Air Products has achieved several early successes in clean hydrogen to date:

  • We announced a pioneering supply agreement in June 2024, a 15-year take-or-pay agreement to supply 70,000 tons of green hydrogen annually to decarbonize TotalEnergies' Northern European refineries starting in 2030. We are also in discussions for green hydrogen supply to its other EU refineries.
  • 60% of capacity for our Canada Net-Zero Hydrogen Energy Project is already committed, and negotiations for the remainder of the capacity are underway.
  • We are the primary EPC contractor and system integrator of the NEOM Green Hydrogen Complex, the largest green-hydrogen-based ammonia production facility that will serve as a key solution for transportation and industrial sectors globally. Air Products is the exclusive off-taker of the green hydrogen produced in the form of green ammonia at the facility.
  • We support Daimler's European Hydrogen Refueling Network project to develop permanent and commercial scale hydrogen refueling stations and have announced networks are being built in California in addition to Canada and Europe.

These important achievements are underpinned by the Board's relentless focus on disciplined capital allocation and risk management controls. We remain focused on delivering on the onstream dates we have outlined and are securing more contracted offtake. The Company expects to generate positive net cash starting in FY2027.

AIR PRODUCTS' BOARD IS REFRESHED, INDEPENDENT AND FIT-FOR-PURPOSE – MANTLE RIDGE'S PROPOSED NOMINEES WOULD REMOVE SIGNIFICANT AND RELEVANT EXPERIENCE AND EXPERTISE FROM THE BOARD

Our Board is committed to strong governance practices, including regular Board refreshment. This is demonstrated through our diverse and continuously enhanced Board composition. With Air Products shareholders supporting our nominations of Mr. Patel and Mr. Stern at the 2025 Annual Meeting, six out of nine Directors will have been first elected in the last five years. Our Board is world-class with expertise across a full range of disciplines, from operations and supply chain optimization to corporate governance and regulations. It consists of individuals with high-caliber executive and leadership experience in chemicals, industrial manufacturing and renewables as well as public company board experience.

Mantle Ridge is seeking to replace four directors who are integral to our Board: Seifollah (Seifi) Ghasemi, Edward L. Monser, Charles Cogut and Lisa A. Davis. If successful, Mantle Ridge's nominees would eliminate significant and relevant expertise brought by these current directors and disrupt the significant progress the Company has made.

Seifollah "Seifi" Ghasemi

Chairman, President and CEO of Air Products

Dennis Reilley

Mantle Ridge Chairman Nominee

 

  • Highly respected executive in industrial gases and specialty chemicals
  • Shareholder in APD with personal stake totaling around $239 million11
  • Incentives highly aligned with shareholders
  • Appointed CEO in 2014 after Pershing Square / Paul Hilal supported his appointment to the Board
  • Significant industry CEO and executive experience
  • Transformed Air Products by creating over $44 billion of shareholder value during his tenure12
  • Built Air Products into the industry leader through organic revenue growth, margin expansion, EPS expansion, and the development and implementation of a Five-Point Plan to guide future success

 

 

Multiple news outlets reported, based on testimony in a federal court plea hearing, that he leaked to a friend non-public information he was privy to during the period he served as a director of Covidien, DowDuPont and Marathon Oil, including, in the case of Covidien, about an upcoming M&A transaction resulting in federal and SEC enforcement charges and fines against the friend and a business associate
-Shortly before public disclosure of reportedly having leaked confidential information and the related enforcement actions, he resigned from three boards and has not served on the board of a public company since such resignations nearly six years ago
- Has not held an executive or operating position in over 17 years
- Owns no shares in APD
- Longstanding relationship with Mr. Hilal from tenure on CSX Board in connection with Mantle Ridge's settlement with CSX and serving as a nominee of Mantle Ridge in its activist fight at Dollar Tree
- Has a two-year consulting agreement with Mantle Ridge, misaligning his interests from those of Air Products' shareholders

 

 

Edward L. Monser

Lead Independent Director of Air Products

Paul Hilal

Mantle Ridge CEO and Nominee

 

  • Significant experience in industrial operations and supply chain optimization
  • Appointed in 2014 with support from Pershing Square / Paul Hilal who stated as recently as October 2024 that: Ed Monser is "the kind of truly independent, high-integrity and shareholder-oriented director nominee [ ] that we think can best serve shareholders13"
  • Over 30 years of experience leading global engineering organizations through strategic change
  • Strong understanding of industrial operations, supply chain optimization and continuous improvement
  • Extensive experience in international business operations in emerging markets

 

 

-No experience with the board or operations of an industrial gas or chemicals company

-Track record of value destruction and mismanaged succession processes at all of Mantle Ridge's public activist campaigns – Aramark, CSX and Dollar Tree – TSR relative to the S&P 500 during his Board tenures decreased at all companies: Dollar Tree -104%, CSX -69% and Aramark -63%14

-Dissident director slate appears assembled largely based on previous relationships and activism involvement as opposed to fit-for-purpose recruitment

-Under his board oversight, CSX said in October 2024 it had received a subpoena from the Securities and Exchange Commission over an accounting restatement, as well as information requests about some of the company's performance metrics

 

Charles Cogut

Independent Director of Air Products

Tracy McKibben

Mantle Ridge Nominee

 

  • Leading corporate lawyer with multi-jurisdictional M&A expertise
  • Regarded as one of the most prominent corporate lawyers in the United States
  • 39-year tenure at Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP where he specialized in: domestic, international and cross-border M&A, the representation of special committees of boards of directors, buyouts and other transactions involving private equity firms
  • Previously served as a director of The Williams Companies, Inc.

 

 

-Less relevant experience than targeted directors

-Appears to have significantly less legal experience than Mr. Cogut

-Energy experience via advisory work is redundant, but on a much less comparable level given Lisa Davis and Alfred Stern's much more significant energy expertise

-Former board experience includes governance issues involving related party transactions and involvement in controversial and unsuccessful activism campaigns

 

Lisa A. Davis

Independent Director of Air Products

Andrew Evans

Mantle Ridge Nominee

 

  • Extensive experience leading world-scale energy projects, including renewables
  • 35-year tenure leading large, multi-faceted international businesses within energy and manufacturing industries, overseeing and implementing world-scale energy projects
  • Served on public boards in the U.S. and Europe, knowledge which is crucial to the Company as it implements complex international projects which are an increasing portion of the business

 

 

-Less relevant experience than targeted directors

-Public executive and board experience limited to the U.S. and affiliation with an activist shareholder campaign

-Industry credentials and renewable energy project experience pale in caliber to those of Lisa Davis

-Oversaw the finances of the Vogtle nuclear power plant expansion project at Southern Co as CEO, which was plagued by construction delays and cost overruns – the project was seven years late and $17 billion over budget

MANTLE RIDGE'S PROPOSED EXECUTIVE CHAIRMAN CANDIDATE APPEARS ALARMINGLY UNFIT TO LEAD AIR PRODUCTS OR ANY PUBLIC COMPANY

The core pillar of Mantle Ridge's efforts is the replacement of the Board's lead independent director, Ed Monser, as well as our Chairman and CEO, Seifi Ghasemi, with its hand-picked successors, Dennis Reilley and Eduardo Menezes. As you consider changes which would upend the leadership at Air Products and derail our momentum, we believe it is important that you are aware of the following facts relating to Mr. Reilley that the Board became aware of during its thorough evaluation of Mantle Ridge's nominees:

  • In February 2019, a purported friend of Mr. Reilley, John Davidson, signed a plea agreement with the United States, admitting to making a false statement to the FBI that he had never received from "D.R." any non-public information, which "D.R." had acquired as a result of his position on the boards of Marathon Oil, DowDuPont, or Covidien.15 The plea agreement used the initials "D.R." only when referring to the director in question. We note that Mr. Reilley was not named directly in the complaint by the United States.
  • Shortly thereafter, the media reported on the charges brought against Mr. Davidson, and noted clearly that the charges stemmed from the FBI's investigation into Dennis Reilley and whether insider information was provided about the impending merger of Covidien PLC, with its rival, Medtronic Inc. The media noted that Mr. Reilley was a director at Covidien.16
  • In December 2019, an associate of Mr. Davidson, John Special, was found liable and ordered to pay nearly $3 million in an SEC enforcement action,17 for allegedly trading on the basis of the information leaked by Mr. Davidson, who had received material, non-public information from a "Director" who served on the boards of Covidien, Marathon Oil and DowDuPont, including, in the case of Covidien, about a proposed transaction between Covidien and Medtronic. We note that Mr. Reilley was not named directly in the SEC's complaint.
  • Notably, before news of the plea agreement and SEC enforcement action became publicly known, in December 2018 and January 2019, Mr. Reilley resigned as director of CSX (to which he had been appointed by Mantle Ridge) and DowDupont (both in December 2018), and as director and chairman of Marathon Oil (in February 2019), respectively. Mr. Reilley has not served on a public company board since these resignations.

A portion of the transcript from the hearing in which Mr. Davidson pled guilty to lying to the FBI regarding who he received information in connection with the Covidien/Medtronic's merger is pasted below. If true, the statements are deeply concerning, as they show the director in question leaked board confidences regularly with his friend:

MS. ANDERSON [Assistant U.S. Attorney]: And he D.R. provided you with nonpublic information he had received from all three of those boards, correct?

THE DEFENDANT: Yes, ma'am.

MS. ANDERSON: And he D.R. forwarded emails he received as a board member?

THE DEFENDANT: Yes, ma'am.

[…]

MS. ANDERSON: You had, in fact, received nonpublic information from D.R. that he had acquired from his board work at Covidien, Marathon and Dow, correct?

THE DEFENDANT: Yes, ma'am.

MS. ANDERSON: And sometime between March 2014 and May 15th, 2014, you specifically learned from D.R. about developing negotiations about Covidien's merger with or acquisition by Medtronic, correct?

THE DEFENDANT: That is correct.

MS. ANDERSON: And you understood that information to be nonpublic, correct?

THE DEFENDANT: Yes, ma'am.

In a statement Mantle Ridge issued on December 13 in response to another media report on the matter, it stated, "To be clear, Mr. Reilley in no way acted inappropriately, and has never been accused of or charged with any impropriety or wrongdoing in connection with the matter." Mantle Ridge also claimed in its response that Mr. Davidson's testimony was "false".

While Mr. Reilley was never formally charged by the FBI or the SEC for any wrongdoing, the information revealed in Mr. Davidson's plea agreement and the SEC's complaint against Mr. Special, if true, raises grave concerns about Mr. Reilley's trustworthiness and ability to comply with his basic duty of confidentiality as a director. Mantle Ridge has offered no reasonable explanation to shareholders regarding this matter, other than to claim the testimony obtained under oath is false.

These circumstances not only call into question Mantle Ridge's judgment in putting Mr. Reilley forward, but also the credibility of the entire Mantle Ridge slate and campaign. In the Board's view, this matter should disqualify Mr. Reilley from ever again serving on a public company board.

MANTLE RIDGE'S PREFERRED CEO CANDIDATE IS INSUFFICIENTLY QUALIFIED

In addition, Mantle Ridge's proposed CEO candidate, Eduardo Menezes, lacks public company CEO or board experience – two key criteria for Air Products' next CEO that the Board established months ago. By proposing a CEO candidate like Mr. Menezes who would require substantial on-the-job training and chaperoning at a pivotal moment for the Company, Mantle Ridge has clearly demonstrated that it is not interested in a thoughtful succession process that would benefit all shareholders and is instead only concerned about its own interests. Mr. Menezes is insufficiently experienced and lacks the basic qualifications our Board is looking for in CEO candidates.

Key CEO Search Qualities Established Before Engagement with Mantle Ridge

by the Air Products Board

Eduardo Menezes

Mantle Ridge CEO Candidate

 

  • Expert track record of value creation and superior industry experience as CEO or Board Director
  • Strong investor relationships and well known to the investor community
  • Current or former public company CEO
  • Significant international experience
  • Global relationships with policymakers and regulators

 

 

-No significant employment experience outside of his tenure at Linde and the company's subsidiaries

-Was passed over for the CEO role at Linde after 35 years with the company, never being promoted beyond EVP and Head of EMEA

-No public company C-suite or board experience

-Retired since leaving Linde in 2021

In contrast to Mantle Ridge's inadequate CEO candidate who fails to meet the Board's previously communicated search criteria, Air Products is advancing with a CEO succession process to find an excellent candidate suited to lead the Company in this next stage of growth. This process was announced in August 2024, prior to D.E. Shaw's, or Mantle Ridge's involvement. The Board has committed to providing an announcement of a new President and related timeline for CEO succession no later than March 31, 2025.

Mr. Hilal and Mantle Ridge have run the same failed playbook in each of its three activist campaigns since its founding. Each case forced major changes, including replacing the CEOs, and have failed to create long-term value for shareholders relative to the S&P 500. Since its founding, Mantle Ridge has never run an activist campaign or made a CEO change that has driven outperformance.

Mantle Ridge's stale, recycled playbook has failed before, and, if implemented at Air Products, would fail again. Mantle Ridge's substandard Chairman and CEO candidates and lack of any credible plan leave us highly concerned that, if successful with its campaign, its actions would derail our clean hydrogen strategy and destroy shareholder value.

SAFEGUARD THE VALUE OF YOUR INVESTMENT IN AIR PRODUCTS BY VOTING "FOR" THE ELECTION OF ALL OF AIR PRODUCTS' NINE NOMINEES ON THE WHITE PROXY CARD

The Board understands its responsibility to deliver value to ALL shareholders. The Board also, with the support of its leadership advisory firm, considered Mantle Ridge's revised slate and unanimously determined these nominees still do not offer qualifications superior to Air Products' well-balanced slate of nominees with the proper skills and experience to lead the Company through its next phase of growth.

  • Tonit M. Calaway, Independent – Executive Vice President, Chief Administrative Officer, General Counsel and Secretary of BorgWarner Inc.
  • Charles "Casey" Cogut, Independent – Retired Partner, Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP
  • Lisa A. Davis, Independent – Former Member of the Managing Board and CEO of Gas and Power for Siemens AG
  • Seifollah "Seifi" Ghasemi, Chairman, President, and CEO
  • Jessica Trocchi Graziano, Independent Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer of United States Steel Corporation
  • Edward L. Monser, Independent, Lead Director – Retired President and Chief Operating Officer of Emerson Electric Co.
  • Bhavesh V. ("Bob") Patel, Independent, New Nominee – Former President of Standard Industries
  • Wayne T. Smith, Independent – Retired Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of BASF Corporation
  • Alfred Stern, Independent, New Nominee – Chief Executive Officer and Chairman of the Executive Board of OMV Aktiengesellschaft

We strongly urge that you vote your shares "FOR" ONLY Air Products' Nominees. Please discard any blue proxy card you may receive from Mantle Ridge.

Thank you for your ongoing support.

Sincerely,

The Air Products Board of Directors

For more information regarding our Board nominees and strategy, please visit: www.voteairproducts.com.

YOUR VOTE IS IMPORTANT. Whether or not you plan to virtually attend the 2025 Annual Meeting, please take a few minutes now to vote by Internet or by telephone by following the instructions on the WHITE proxy card, or to sign, date and return the enclosed WHITE proxy card in the enclosed postage-paid envelope provided. Regardless of the number of Company shares you own, your presence by proxy is helpful to establish a quorum and your vote is important.


OUR BOARD OF DIRECTORS UNANIMOUSLY RECOMMENDS A VOTE "FOR" ONLY AIR PRODUCTS' NINE NOMINEES AND PROPOSALS ON THE ENCLOSED WHITE PROXY CARD.

If you have any questions or require any assistance with voting your shares,
please call the Company's proxy solicitor:

Innisfree M&A Incorporated

501 Madison Avenue, 20th Floor

New York, New York 10022

Shareholders: 1 (877) 750-0537 (toll-free from the U.S. and Canada)

or +1 (412) 232-3651 (from other countries)


About Air Products
Air Products (NYSE: APD) is a world-leading industrial gases company in operation for over 80 years focused on serving energy, environmental, and emerging markets and generating a cleaner future. The Company supplies essential industrial gases, related equipment and applications expertise to customers in dozens of industries, including refining, chemicals, metals, electronics, manufacturing, medical and food. As the leading global supplier of hydrogen, Air Products also develops, engineers, builds, owns and operates some of the world's largest clean hydrogen projects, supporting the transition to low- and zero-carbon energy in the industrial and heavy-duty transportation sectors. Through its sale of equipment businesses, the Company also provides turbomachinery, membrane systems and cryogenic containers globally.

Air Products had fiscal 2024 sales of $12.1 billion from operations in approximately 50 countries and has a current market capitalization of over $65 billion. Approximately 23,000 passionate, talented and committed employees from diverse backgrounds are driven by Air Products' higher purpose to create innovative solutions that benefit the environment, enhance sustainability and reimagine what's possible to address the challenges facing customers, communities, and the world. For more information, visit airproducts.com or follow us on LinkedInXFacebook or Instagram.

Non-GAAP Financial Measures
This communication contains certain financial measures that are not prepared in accordance with U.S. generally accepted accounting principles ("GAAP"), including adjusted EPS, adjusted EBITDA, and adjusted EBITDA margin. On our website, at investors.airproducts.com, we have included definitions and reconciliations of these non-GAAP financial measures to the most directly comparable financial measures prepared in accordance with GAAP. Management believes these non-GAAP financial measures provide investors, potential investors, securities analysts, and others with useful information to evaluate our business because such measures, when viewed together with our GAAP disclosures, provide a more complete understanding of the factors and trends affecting our business. The non-GAAP financial measures supplement our GAAP disclosures and are not meant to be considered in isolation or as a substitute for the most directly comparable measures prepared in accordance with GAAP. These measures may not be comparable to similarly titled measures used by other companies.

Forward-Looking Statements
This communication contains "forward-looking statements" within the safe harbor provisions of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. These forward-looking statements are based on management's expectations and assumptions as of the date of this communication and are not guarantees of future performance. While forward-looking statements are made in good faith and based on assumptions, expectations and projections that management believes are reasonable based on currently available information, actual performance and financial results may differ materially from projections and estimates expressed in the forward-looking statements because of many factors, including the risk factors described in our Annual Report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended September 30, 2024 and other factors disclosed in our filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission. Except as required by law, we disclaim any obligation or undertaking to update or revise any forward-looking statements contained herein to reflect any change in the assumptions, beliefs or expectations or any change in events, conditions or circumstances upon which any such forward-looking statements are based.

Investor Inquiries:

Eric Guter, tel: (610) 481-1872; email: guterej@airproducts.com Mun Shieh, tel:  (610) 481-2951; shiehmh@airproducts.com

1Based on $25.2B market capitalization on June 30, 2014 (one day prior to first day as CEO) and December 13, 2024

2Based on $25.2B market capitalization on June 30, 2014 (one day prior to Seifi Ghasemi's first day as CEO) and December 13, 2024­

3Based on $25.2B market capitalization on June 30, 2014 (one day prior to Seifi Ghasemi's first day as CEO) and December 13, 2024

4Non-GAAP financial measure. Visit investors.airproducts.com for reconciliation.

5Non-GAAP financial measure. Visit investors.airproducts.com for reconciliation.

6Peers include Air Liquide, Linde and Nippon Sanso. Air Products based on GAAP sales CAGR from 9/30/14 to 9/30/24 as reclassified to give effect to divestitures of the PMD and EMD businesses. Air Liquide based on CAGR from 12/31/14 to 12/31/24(E) and is adjusted for its acquisition of Airgas. Linde based on CAGR from 12/31/16 to 12/31/24(E) and is adjusted for its combination with Praxair. Nippon Sanso based on CAGR from 3/31/18 to 3/31/25(E) and is adjusted for its acquisition of Praxair European Assets. Starting revenue data-point is converted to USD at historical FX rate

7Non-GAAP financial measure. Visit investors.airproducts.com for reconciliation.

8Source: International Energy Agency World Energy Outlook 2022

9Source: Deloitte 2023 Global Green Hydrogen Outlook

10Science Direct – Direct 2021; Emerging carbon abatement technologies to mitigate energy-carbon footprint- a review

11Ownership value based on APD share price as of 12/13/2024

12Based on $25.2B market capitalization on June 30, 2014 (one day prior to first day as CEO) and December 13, 2024

13Permission to use quote neither sought nor obtained

14TSR Reflects dividend-adjusted total return percentage over tenure or as of 12/13/2024 for current positions

15United States of America v. John Kenneth Davidson, Case No. 19-cr-56, filed on February 25, 2019. Transcript Dated March 5, 2019.

16Nolan Clay, The Oklahoman, February 27, 2019, "FBI insider trading probe results in criminal charge in Oklahoma City federal court"

17Securities and Exchange Commission v. Special et al, Case No. 19-cv-1152, filed on December 12, 2019.

Cision View original content:https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/air-products-files-investor-presentation-highlighting-successful-two-pillar-strategy-to-deliver-superior-shareholder-value-302335505.html

SOURCE Air Products

FAQ

What is Air Products' (APD) two-pillar growth strategy?

Air Products' two-pillar strategy focuses on growing its core industrial gas business while developing its position in the clean hydrogen market, with over 50% of FY 2023-2025 capital expenditures allocated to the core business.

How much shareholder value has APD created under CEO Seifi Ghasemi since 2014?

Under CEO Seifi Ghasemi's leadership since 2014, Air Products has created over $44 billion in total shareholder value, including dividends.

What are the key financial achievements of APD under current management?

Key achievements include 1,400bps expansion in adjusted EBITDA margin, ~11% adjusted EPS CAGR, and 42 consecutive years of dividend increases with ~9% CAGR over the past decade.

What major clean hydrogen agreements has APD secured recently?

APD secured a 15-year take-or-pay agreement with TotalEnergies to supply 70,000 tons of green hydrogen annually starting in 2030, and has 60% committed capacity for its Canada Net-Zero Hydrogen Energy Project.

When does APD expect positive net cash flow from its clean hydrogen investments?

Air Products expects to generate positive net cash from its clean hydrogen investments starting in FY2027.

Air Products & Chemicals, Inc.

NYSE:APD

APD Rankings

APD Latest News

APD Stock Data

65.21B
221.50M
0.4%
91.48%
1.44%
Specialty Chemicals
Industrial Inorganic Chemicals
Link
United States of America
ALLENTOWN